Hush-Hush
Fifth Third is going to put a vote before its shareholders to accept TARP funding. The meeting is scheduled on Dec. 29th. Fifth Third will receive $3.46 billion in funding through the US Treasury’s Capital Purchase Program.
You could argue that making a major capital decision with public money on a two-day work week between Christmas and New Year’s is a little bit opaque. That would hardly be out of character with recent events, though. Remember that Bank of America’s acquisition of Merrill Lynch was approved on the Friday after Thanksgiving. And of course there was Paulson’s initial plan to not allow any oversight of the $700 billion TARP.
So it should not be that surprising that banks are turning out to be less than forthcoming about how they are actually using our public money.
There is an article by the Associated Press today, revealing that the 21 banks that have already received TARP funds are uniformly hush-hush on how they will use the money. So, although they are taking public money, there is no oversight function for its use.
- “We’re not sharing any other details. We’re just not at this time.” — Comerica
- “I just would prefer if you wouldn’t say that we’re not going to discuss those details.” – Bank of New York Mellon
- “We’re not providing dollar-in, dollar-out tracking,” — SunTrust
Secrecy is a bad policy. The truth has a way of coming out. Being secretive, as was most evident by the spokesperson for Bank of New York Mellon, encourages inquiring minds to dig deeper. Certainly, they have already drawn the ire and curiousity of Scott Garrett, a New Jersey Republican who sits on the House Financial Services committee.
The banks are going to be caught holding the money, or making the same kind of loans that led to the credit crisis. Wait until we hear that TARP money is fueling payday lending, RALs, or pawn shop lending.

