I made a map that compares the number of tax filers who used a refund anticipation loan with the number of tax filers who made an IRA contribution, on a county level, for North Carolina in 2006.
It is possible that a filer might do both. I cannot account for a double counting. I do not think that there were many instances of double counting, though. That is due to the nature of who gets a RAL. RALs (refund anticipation loans) generally go to filers who have very little in the way of liquid assets. They are not the kind of people who can afford to put money away for forty years. Heck, their decision to use a RAL tells us that they can’t even wait 9 days to use their money.
The two smaller maps, in the insets, show the distribution of poverty and wage income. Poverty is on the left, wage income on the right. The poverty map counts the percent of households in poverty. The wage income map shows the percentage of households with wage income.
A glance at the maps would seem to say that there is a much closer correlation between poverty and RAL use than between wage income and RAL use. That makes sense, although it is not a slam dunk – most RAL filers do have jobs because most RAL filers are getting the earned income tax credit. In North Carolina, about 40 percent of EITC recipients get a RAL, and another 20 percent get a refund anticipation check (RAC). There are fees for both, although the RAL fees are much higher.
This map shows the dynamics of our economy. In a large section of eastern North Carolina, many people are living on the margins. They are not saving for the future. They can’t save for 9 days. The rest of the state is hardly better. Most of this map is pink or red – meaning that fewer people are getting ahead than are trying to catch up. The grey areas show were family finances in order. These, for the most part, are the growth areas in the new North Carolina along I-85. There is also a concentration of wealth building in some of the areas that have attracted many retirees.

Ratio of RAL use to IRA contribution, 2006